Report Summary
This report provides members of the Scottish Police Authority Policing Performance Committee with an overview of the key findings and insights gained from the in-depth, aggregated analysis of four waves of Authority commissioned independent public polling.
To access the full document please open the PDF document above.
To view as accessible content please use the sections below. (Note that tables and some appendixes are not available as accessible content).
Meeting
The publication discussed was referenced in the meeting below
Policing Performance Committee - 11 June 2024
Date : 11 June 2024
Location : online
Aggregated Sample Overview & Composition
The aggregated waves of SPA polling data form an overall sample size of 10,562 people from across Scotland, all of whom have been selected randomly from the larger ScotPulse panel of more than 43,000 people.
Wave 1 was collected in July 2022 and consists of 2,594 people.
Wave 2 was collected in February 2023 and consists of 2,663 people.
Wave 3 was collected in July 2023 and consists of 2,718 people and;
Wave 4 was collected in January 2024 and consists of 2,587 people.
These similarly-sized samples, each of a statistically significant size in their own right, were therefore collected at roughly six-monthly intervals over an 18-month period, and collectively form a very large overall sample size to enable reliable sub-group analysis.
An indication of the diversity across the overall aggregated sample of 10,562 is shown below.
It should be noted that when analysing the sample, statistical weightings (by age and gender) are applied to individual responses to ensure a balance with what is known about the size and structure of the wider Scottish population. Applying weightings increases the sample’s representativeness and therefore its reliability when speaking for the population of Scotland as a whole.
Aggregated Sample Composition
Gender
51.8% Women
48.2% Men
Geography
30.8% from East Command
27.2% from North Command
41.7% from West Command
Urban-Rural
35% Large Urban Areas
33% Other Urban Areas
8.5% Accessible Small Towns
4.4% Remote Small Towns
12.3% Accessible Rural Areas
6.9% Remote Rural Areas
SIMD
16.3% from SIMD Quintile 1
18.9% from SIMD Quintile 2
21.9% from SIMD Quintile 3
22% from SIMD Quintile 4
21% from SIMD Quintile 5
Age Group
12.4% aged 16-24
16.5% aged 25-34
14.9% aged 35-44
16.4% aged 45-54
16.5% aged 55-64
23.3% aged 65+
Household Composition
17.2% 1 Person Household
44% 2 Person Household
19.2% 3 Person Household
14.5% 4 Person Household
4% 5 Person Household
1.1% 6 Persons+ in Household
National Level Picture
The following summaries describe what our polling has recorded the Scottish population aged 16+ think about policing, extending back to the summer of 2022, and based on an aggregated sample of 10,562 respondents.
Most peoples’ views are positive, however a long-term trend of declining trust and confidence has been evidenced as in existence for more than a decade (as published in Scottish Crime and Justice Survey findings), and this is evident across the four waves of SPA polling. It should be noted that the overall decline in this recent period is marginal.
The summary below is split into three sections based on question theme, namely Trust, Confidence, and Performance. Note that respondents who did not provide an answer or otherwise express a view (e.g. “don’t know” or “not applicable”) have been excluded from the analysis. Confidence and Trust levels in the survey are derived using an 11-point scoring method, ranging from 0-10. High Confidence and Trust relates to scores of 7 out of 10 or more, and Medium Confidence and Trust relates to scores of 4 to 6 out of 10.
Trust – Scotland as a whole
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that refer to the highest level of trust in the police:
77.6% have high-medium trust in Police Scotland overall
77% have high-medium trust in their local police
72.4% have high-medium trust that the police will protect them
70.9% have high-medium trust that the police care about people like them
69.6% have high-medium trust in the police listening and responding to their needs Respondents in the January 2024 poll were also asked whether their trust in the police had changed in the previous 12 months. 63.7% of respondents reported no change, 5.4% had more trust, and 30.9% had less trust.
Confidence – Scotland as a whole
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that refer to the highest level of confidence in the police:
80.5% have high-medium confidence in Police Scotland overall
79.1% have high-medium confidence in their local police
72.3% have high-medium confidence in the police keeping their area safe
70.1% have high-medium confidence in the police tackling crime in their local area
67.2% have high-medium confidence in the police being there when people need them
66.2% have high-medium confidence in the police preventing crime in their local area
64.8% have high-medium confidence in the police providing an appropriate and timely response
60.6% have high-medium confidence in the police tackling antisocial behaviour in their local area Respondents in the January 2024 wave were also asked whether their confidence in the police had changed in the previous 12 months. 57.1% of respondents reported no change, 6.8% were more confident, and 36.1% were less confident.
Performance – Scotland as a whole
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that rate the police as doing a good job:
73.1% think that the police in general are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly
69.7% think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, at keeping their area safe
65.9% think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, at tackling crime
54.5% think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, at tackling antisocial behaviour
53.6% think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, in bringing the community closer together.
Variations by social, economic and geographic factors
Variations in the overall findings become evident when the data is broken down into sub-groups of the population along demographic, social, economic and geographic lines. By way of illustration, the data presented below shows how various sub-groups responded to the single question of how much confidence they have in policing in Scotland in general terms. The sub-groups are sorted by the maximum range among responses.
% expressing high or medium confidence in policing generally
Gender – 76.3% to 84.6%
RANGE 8.3%
Women 84.6%
Men 76.3%
Scottish Parliamentary Region – 76% to 83.6%
RANGE 7.6%
Highland and Islands 83.6%
Lothian 81.3%
West Scotland 80.8%
North East Scotland 80.7%
Mid Scotland, Fife 80.5%
Central Scotland 80.3%
South Scotland 80%
Glasgow 76.0%
SIMD – 77.6% to 82.6%
RANGE 5%
SIMD 5 (least deprived) 82.6%
SIMD 3 80.9%
SIMD 4 80.1%
SIMD 2 80%
SIMD 1 (most deprived) 77.6%
Age Band – 77.8% to 82.5%
RANGE 4.7%
65+ 82.5%
55-64 81.2%
25-34 80.7%
35-44 79.8%
45-54 79.3%
16-24 77.8%
Urban-Rural Classification – 79.5% to 83.9%
RANGE 4.4%
Remote Rural 83.9%
Remote Small Towns 82.2%
Accessible-Rural 82.2%
Other Urban Areas 80.2%
Accessible Small Towns 79.6%
Large Urban Areas 79.5%
Household Composition – 78.6% to 81.8%
RANGE 3.2%
2-person household 81.8%
6 or more-person household 80.7%
3–5-person household 79.9%
Single person household 78.6%
At this macro level, the single most important of the factors under investigation is gender, which is notably stronger than age band, the other main demographic factor. Parliamentary region is also strong, with a clear contrast evident between Highland and Islands and Glasgow, yet very similar levels across the rest of Scotland. There is also evidence of different views according to SIMD category, with people living in less deprived communities expressing the most confidence. Household size is the least significant of the factors available for investigation.
It is important to note that some factors, when combined with other factors, can become much more powerful than at the single factor level where underlying variations are often masked.
The Views of Women
As has been shown so far, at the single-factor level, a respondent’s gender appears to influence their view of the police in Scotland, with women generally having more confidence in the police than men.
The following summaries describe what women in Scotland aged 16+ think about different aspects of policing in comparison with men. A total of 5,471 women were polled during the four waves, and their response rate to questions on confidence, trust and policing performance ranged from 79.4% to 92.8% depending on the question being asked. In the case of men, 5,091 were polled during the four waves, with a valid opinion response rate to individual questions ranging from 86.7% to 95.6%. Across all polling questions, women are more likely than men to choose ‘opinionless’ options such as “Don’t Know” or “Not Applicable” or “No Opinion”, which are discounted from the analysis.
The analysis shows that among people expressing their views on the police in relation to confidence, trust and police performance, women are much more likely to give a positive response. This gender-based positivity applies to some aspects of policing, crime, and personal and community safety more than others, as detailed below. In terms of the largest differences, women are more likely to say that the police generally are doing a good job, particularly at tackling crime, and women have greater trust that the police will protect them, and care about them. Women are also more likely than men to say that their trust and confidence in the police has changed over the last 12 months, with a greater proportion of women than men reporting being more confident.
Confidence – Women compared with men
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that show the largest differences between the views of women versus men:
84.6% of women have high-medium confidence in Police Scotland overall compared with 76.3% for men - 8.3% higher
64.1% of women have high-medium confidence in the police tackling antisocial behaviour in their local area compared with 57% of men – 7.1% higher
70.5% of women have high-medium confidence in the police being there when people need them compared with 63.6% for men – 6.9% higher
67.8% of women have high-medium confidence in the police providing an appropriate and timely response compared with 61.9% for men – 5.9% higher
81.4% of women have high-medium confidence in their local police compared with 76.5% for men - 4.9% higher
68.5% of women have high-medium confidence in the police preventing crime in their local area compared with 63.7% for men – 4.8% higher
74.6% of women have high-medium confidence in the police keeping their area safe compared with 70% for men – 4.6% higher
72.4% of women have high-medium confidence in the police tackling crime in their local area compared with 67.8% for men – 4.6% higher
Respondents in the January 2024 poll were also asked whether their confidence in the police had changed in the previous 12 months. 56.7% of women reported no change, compared with 57.7% of men. 7.9% of women were more confident, compared with 5.7% of men.
Trust – Women compared with men
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that show the largest differences between the views of women versus men:
74.7% of women have high-medium trust that the police care about people like them compared with 66.9% for men – 7.8% higher
76% of women have high-medium trust that the police will protect
them compared with 68.6% for men – 7.4% higher
72.9% of women have high-medium trust in the police listening and responding to their needs compared with 66% for men – 6.9% higher
80.1% of women have high-medium trust in Police Scotland overall compared with 75.1% for men - 5% higher
78.9% of women have high-medium trust in their local police compared with 75.1% for men – 3.8% higher
Respondents in the January 2024 poll were also asked whether their trust in the police had changed in the previous 12 months. 60.9% of women reported no change, compared with 66.7% of men. 6.7% of women had more trust, compared with 4% of men.
Performance – women compared with men
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that show the largest differences between the views of women versus men:
77.7% of women think that the police in general are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, compared with 68.3% for men – 9.4% higher
69.9% of women think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, at tackling crime, compared with 61.8% for men – 8.1% higher
73% of women think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, at keeping their area safe, compared with 66.4% for men – 6.6% higher
56.8% of women think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, in bringing the community closer together, compared with 50.3% for men – 6.5% higher
57.1% of women think that the police in are doing a good/very good job, or at least performing fairly, at tackling antisocial behaviour, compared with 51.9% for men – 5.2% higher
Variations within the views of Women
Variations in the overall findings for women become evident when the data is broken down further, by demographic, social, economic and geographic lines. To illustrate this, the data presented below shows how various sub-groups of women responded to the three core questions of how much confidence they have in policing in Scotland in general terms, how much trust they have in the police in Scotland, whether they think the police are generally doing a good job, and whether their confidence and trust in the police has changed during the last 12 months. Each question area’s sub groups are sorted by the maximum range among responses.
Confidence in the Police Among Women
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that show the largest differences among the views of women:
% of women expressing high or medium confidence in policing generally
Household Composition – 79.1% to 85.6%
RANGE 6.5%
2-person household 85.6%
3–5-person household 84.4%
6 or more-person household 81.0%
Single person household 79.1%
Urban-Rural Classification – 82.9% to 89.1%
RANGE 6.2%
Remote Small Towns 89.1%
Remote Rural 87.6%
Accessible-Rural 85.4%
Accessible Small Towns 84.5%
Other Urban Areas 83.9%
Large Urban Areas 82.9%
Scottish Parliamentary Region – 81.2% to 86.3%
RANGE 5.1%
Highland and Islands 86.3%
Mid Scotland, Fife 85.7%
Central Scotland 85.5%
South Scotland 85.2%
North East Scotland 84.5%
West Scotland 84.0%
Lothian 83.7%
Glasgow 81.2%
Age Band – 81.1% to 85.8%
RANGE 4.3%
35-44 85.8%
65+ 85.4%
55-64 84.7%
45-54 84.6%
25-34 84.5%
16-24 81.1%
SIMD – 83.2% to 85.4%
RANGE 2.2%
SIMD 5 (least deprived) 84.5%
SIMD 4 84.0%
SIMD 3 83.7%
SIMD 1 (most deprived) 81.2%
SIMD 285.8%
Trust in the Police Among Women
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that show the largest differences among the views of women:
% of women expressing high or medium trust in policing generally
Age Band – 72.5% to 82.6%
RANGE 10.1%
65+ 82.6%
35-44 82.0%
55-64 81.0%
45-54 81.0%
25-34 78.8%
16-24 72.5%
Scottish Parliamentary Region – 76.4% to 85.2%
RANGE 8.8%
South Scotland 85.2%
Highland and Islands 84.2%
Mid Scotland, Fife 81.3%
North East Scotland 80.9%
West Scotland 80.0%
Central Scotland 78.8%
Lothian 78.7%
Glasgow 76.4%
SIMD – 76.5% to 84.1%
RANGE 7.6%
SIMD 5 (least deprived) 84.1%
SIMD 4 80.4%
SIMD 3 80.4%
SIMD 1 (most deprived) 78.4%
SIMD 2 76.5%
Urban-Rural Classification – 78.1% to 83.6%
RANGE 5.5%
Remote Rural 83.6%
Remote Small Towns 83.1%
Accessible-Rural 81.4%
Accessible Small Towns 80.8%
Other Urban Areas 79.6%
Large Urban Areas 78.1%
Household Composition – 79.1% to 81.4%
RANGE 2.3%
2-person household 81.4%
6 or more-person household 80.3%
3–5-person household 79.2%
Single person household 79.1%
Women’s views on Police Performance
The following statements are listed in order, starting with those that show the largest differences among the views of women:
% of women saying that the police are doing a good or very good job, or at least performing fairly.
Urban-Rural Classification – 71.2% to 81%
RANGE 9.8%
Remote Rural 81.0%
Remote Small Towns 80.7%
Accessible-Rural 79.9%
Other Urban Areas 77.8%
Large Urban Areas 77.3%
Accessible Small Towns 71.2%
Scottish Parliamentary Region – 74.2% to 80.9%
RANGE 6.7%
Highland and Islands 80.9%
Mid Scotland, Fife 79.7%
South Scotland 78.5%
North East Scotland 77.9%
Central Scotland 77.9%
Lothian 77.3%
West Scotland 75.4%
Glasgow 74.2%
Age Band – 74.3% to 80.1%
RANGE 5.8%
35-44 80.1%
25-34 79.3%
65+ 78.1%
55-64 77.1%
45-54 76.7%
16-24 74.3%
SIMD – 74.2% to 79.8%
RANGE 5.6%
SIMD 5 (least deprived) 79.8%
SIMD 3 78.9%
SIMD 4 78.5%
SIMD 2 77.1%
SIMD 1 (most deprived) 74.2%
Household Composition – 75.4% to 79.7%
RANGE 4.3%
6 or more-person household 79.7%
2-person household 78.6%
3–5-person household 77.8%
Single person household 75.4%
Changing Levels of Confidence and Trust among Women
In January 2024 (Wave 4), 1,340 women were asked whether their views on the police had changed over the past 12 months in terms of their confidence and trust. The results among women, when broken down into sub-categories, are detailed below, initially for confidence and then trust, and sorted by the factors with the greatest amount of difference.
Changing Confidence
% of women saying that their level of confidence had improved or remained the same over the previous 12 months.
Household Composition – 59.8% to 83.3%
RANGE 23.5%
6 or more-person household 83.3%
3–5-person household 67.5%
2-person household 63.4%
Single person household 59.8%
Urban-Rural Classification – 62.1% to 76.3%
RANGE 14.2%
Remote Rural 76.3%
Remote Small Towns 69.0%
Accessible Small Towns 66.3%
Other Urban Areas 63.9%
Large Urban Areas 63.0%
Accessible-Rural 62.1%
Age Band – 61.8% to 75.0%
RANGE 13.2%
16-24 75.0%
25-34 64.1%
35-44 63.9%
45-54 63.3%
65+ 62.7%
55-64 61.8%
Scottish Parliamentary Region – 59.6% to 72.6%
RANGE 13%
Highland and Islands 72.6%
Lothian 70.4%
Central Scotland 66.1%
West Scotland 64.4%
South Scotland 64.3%
North East Scotland 60.2%
Glasgow 60.5%
Mid Scotland, Fife 59.6%
SIMD – 60.8% to 69.0%
RANGE 8.2%
SIMD 3 69.0%
SIMD 5 (least deprived) 67.2%
SIMD 1 (most deprived) 63.3%
SIMD 2 62.3%
SIMD 4 60.8%
Changing Trust
% of women saying that their level of trust had improved or remained the same over the previous 12 months.
Household Composition – 64.4% to 83.3%
RANGE 18.9%
6 or more-person household 83.3%
3–5-person household 70.2%
2-person household 66.0%
Single person household 64.4%
Scottish Parliamentary Region – 59.8% to 75.8%
RANGE 16%
Highland and Islands 75.8%
Lothian 72.1%
South Scotland 70.1%
West Scotland 66.5%
Mid Scotland, Fife 66.5%
North East Scotland 65.9%
Central Scotland 64.8%
Glasgow 59.8%
Urban-Rural Classification – 65.8% to 81.4%
RANGE 15.6%
Remote Small Towns 81.4%
Remote Rural 72.2%
Accessible Small Towns 68.6%
Accessible-Rural 68.3%
Other Urban Areas 67.0%
Large Urban Areas 65.8%
SIMD – 64.5% to 70.8%
RANGE 6.3%
SIMD 5 (least deprived) 70.8%
SIMD 3 70.1%
SIMD 2 68.4%
SIMD 4 65.1%
SIMD 1 (most deprived) 64.5%
Age Band – 66.7% to 70.9%
RANGE 4.2%
16-24 70.9%
35-44 68.1%
45-54 67.6%
65+ 67.0%
25-34 66.7%
55-64 66.7%
Summary of Key Points from the Deeper Dive
Trust in Scottish policing remains strong, and most people think that the police are doing a good job (or are at least performing fairly). The public does, however, think that the police are not performing as well when it comes to building more cohesive communities.
Confidence in policing remains mostly strong, with confidence being
greater for policing services generally, including local, community
policing. There is notably less confidence in the population in
relation to tackling antisocial behaviour, although women do have
more confidence than men in this regard by some margin.
Gender is the most important single factor in influencing levels of trust and confidence in the police, and views about policing performance, with women being more positive than men across a suite of indicators. Notably women are more likely to say that the police care about them, are providing protection, and are listening and responding to their needs.
Among women there is a great deal of variation depending on circumstances. Women who live in a two person household tend to be more confident in the police than those who live alone. Women who live in rural areas or small towns tend to show more confidence than those who live in urban areas. Trust among women aged 65+ is higher than women aged 16-24, although the last 12 months has seen more younger women changing their level of trust positively than has been the case for other women.
Geography and deprivation continue to influence the overall findings, with women living in more affluent and rural communities
expressing more confidence and trust in the police than others, and rating police performance more positively.